I think White can bring his queen out for a price or get some compensation for it, but it's about doing so in the right circumstances. I had a few ideas: Bd3xg6 gives White a lot of pawns for rook v two pieces, but Black has a lot of lines. b3 causes trouble when the bishop emerges, but doesn't work immediately. g4-g5 would get White a rook and piece for the queen, and give him two rooms plus pawns v queen; this would need preparing with Bb5 or Rg1.
My move was the more ambitious 1. Nb5, threatening Nxc7+:
1. ... Na6 feels like the wrong way for the knight, and I think 2. b3 works now, as 2. ... 0-0-0 3. Nxa7+ and Nxc6, with the b-pawn overloaded.
1. ... Bxb5 2. Bxb5+ removes Black's most dangerous piece, so after 2. ... c6 3. Bd3 is a better version of the above, and 2. ... Nbd7 3. g4 likewise.
1. ... Kd7 2. b3 Bg7 3. Ba3 and White swaps the queens (3. ... Qf7 4. Bc4); it costs a piece, but with the queens off there's less danger in the position.
No points this time I’m afraid. HIARCS seems to like 1 Nb5 in all lines other than 1 ... Bxb5 2 Bxb5 Nc6 which it seems to think is more or less equal.
I went for 1 Bb5 (only 2 points for me) but I did consider 1 Nb5. I’ll put some more comments in the feedback post in the next day or so.
"By isolating the basic elements of master and grandmaster games, Simple Chess attempts to break down the mystique of chess strategy into plain, clear, easy-to-understand ideas." Michael Stean
"Why is Black lost? Material is equal and White hasn’t got a piece beyond the second rank. The answer lies in the pawns. White has two beautiful squares on c4 and d5 plus a mobile pawn roller on the left flank, whereas Black’s pawns constrict his own pieces terribly, particularly the bishop." Michael Stean
If each player is capable of quick development, castling and of not blundering any pieces away, what is there to separate the two sides? This is the starting point of Simple Chess . - Michael Stean
I think White can bring his queen out for a price or get some compensation for it, but it's about doing so in the right circumstances. I had a few ideas: Bd3xg6 gives White a lot of pawns for rook v two pieces, but Black has a lot of lines. b3 causes trouble when the bishop emerges, but doesn't work immediately. g4-g5 would get White a rook and piece for the queen, and give him two rooms plus pawns v queen; this would need preparing with Bb5 or Rg1.
ReplyDeleteMy move was the more ambitious 1. Nb5, threatening Nxc7+:
1. ... Na6 feels like the wrong way for the knight, and I think 2. b3 works now, as 2. ... 0-0-0 3. Nxa7+ and Nxc6, with the b-pawn overloaded.
1. ... Bxb5 2. Bxb5+ removes Black's most dangerous piece, so after 2. ... c6 3. Bd3 is a better version of the above, and 2. ... Nbd7 3. g4 likewise.
1. ... Kd7 2. b3 Bg7 3. Ba3 and White swaps the queens (3. ... Qf7 4. Bc4); it costs a piece, but with the queens off there's less danger in the position.
Hi Adam,
DeleteNo points this time I’m afraid. HIARCS seems to like 1 Nb5 in all lines other than 1 ... Bxb5 2 Bxb5 Nc6 which it seems to think is more or less equal.
I went for 1 Bb5 (only 2 points for me) but I did consider 1 Nb5. I’ll put some more comments in the feedback post in the next day or so.
Ah, way off the mark with this one. I found it hard to get my bearings. Be interested to hear more lines...
Delete