BtM 12A: The first one
September 1988, Position A
Black to play
Ivanchuk - Norwood, European Junior Campionship 1987
Contributions are welcome in the comments box. I’ll reply with what the Masters have to say about their choice to anybody who suggests a move.
Scroll down to see some commentary from me and the Masters’ feedback.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"Will I ever be allowed to forget my tragedies at the European Junior Championship in Arnhem?"
- David Norwood
As well as knowing the games that other people have played (BtM 11), it’s a pretty good idea to know your own.
Norwood played 18 … Rfb8 in the game against Ivanchuk and later lost after trying to win a position in which he could have forced a draw. Later he felt that Black could improve in today’s position with … Nf6. The panel might not have agreed, but according to the HIARCS opening book the position has now been played 14 times at a high level and hitting the queen is played much more frequently and scores quite a bit better.
This position, by the way, was the very first Beat the Masters I looked at when I began playing through the series after lockdown started.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
POINTS
10: … Rfb8
8: … Nf6
5: … Rxa2
3: … Qc3, … Qxa2
1: … f5
MASTERS
… Rfb8: Flear, P. Littlewood, Keene, Pein, J. Littlewood, Botterill, S. Arkell, Horner
… Nf6: Norwood, K. Arkell, Conchess Plymate
SOURCE
… Rfb8 Ivanchuk - Norwood, European Junior Championship 1987
Yesterday Jack chose 1 ... Rfb8.
ReplyDeleteA few additional comments from Norwood:-
"Whilst I hold that 18 ... Rf8 is equal, I think that 18 ... Nf6 gives Black the initiative.
a) 19 Qe5 Rxa2 intending 20 ... Re8 with a big advantag.
b) 19 Qf4 Re8 with gan of temp on previous analysis.
c) 19 Qd3 Rc8!, 20 Qc4 R8b8, 21 e3 Rxa2, 22 Be2 R8b2, 23 0-0 Rxd2 and I claim to be better."
Typo: that should read, "Whilst I hold that 18 ... Rfb8 is equal ...."
DeleteI haven’t analysed this position extensively with an engine but HIARCS seems to think that 1 ... Rfb8, 2 Qf4 (not mentioned by the BtM panel) is an extremely strong reply. In fact if HIARCS is right Black may just be lost.
So it seems that 1 ... Nf6 is probably the better move although whether it gives Black an advantage or not is another question.
Tried to comment yesterday but failed. I went for Rfb8, though wasn't convinced after Qf4. I rejected Nf6 due to Qd3, as I missed Rc8.
ReplyDeleteHi Adam,
ReplyDeleteGood to see you.
Qf4 was a good spot, at least. And ... Rc8 is one of those moves that’s quite hard to see, I think, stopping off along the way to where you want to end up. At least they are for me.